Bertot, John C.Wimmer, Maria A.Janssen, MarijnMacintosh, AnnScholl, Hans JochenTambouris, Efthimios2018-10-122018-10-122013978-3-88579-615-2https://dl.gi.de/handle/20.500.12116/17283Journal excellence rests on at least three essential factors: 1) the journal's editorial team; 2) the strength of the research community; and 3) the peer review process. In particular, a critical review process that assesses the strengths and weaknesses of submitted manuscripts is a necessity if a journal is to publish high quality articles that are read, cited, and have an impact on both research and practice. This workshop is designed to provide attendees with insights into how to conduct useful and rigorous manuscript reviews.enText/Conference Paper1617-5468